I Don’t Know Their Story

March 15, 2018

The following is my weekly letter to the Bishop Chatard HS parent community:

Some of the best advice I have ever received was given to me about seven or eight years ago. It was the first night I worked with HOOP, an organization serving the homeless in and around downtown Indianapolis. We bring food, clothing, blankets, hats, gloves, etc. to homeless people living along the river or under bridges. Steve, the crew leader for the night, was putting me through a brief orientation. He told me, “When someone comes forward and tells us what they need, we don’t second guess their needs. We just serve them.” Then the life-changing advice came: “We don’t judge people because we don’t know their story.” That advice hit me hard and has stuck with me. It has changed how I interact with people – all people, not just the homeless. It has helped me become a less judgmental person, as well as a more compassionate one.

It can be challenging not to judge behaviors based solely on appearance and experience. We tend to paint people with some pretty wide brushes. That student was just disrespectful to me. Was that a disrespectful student or is something driving the behavior? The parent in my office is being very unreasonable. Is this an unreasonable parent or is something driving the behavior? My son is being sloppy and lazy (or maybe sloppier and lazier than normal). Is there something that is driving this behavior?

It can also be challenging not to match attitudes that are presented to us. For example, if someone approaches us with anger, we are likely to show anger in return. If someone addresses us using a sharp or sarcastic tone, we will likely use a similar tone in the response. You get the idea.

As a Lenten challenge to ourselves, what would happen if our initial response to all of the aforementioned situations was to pause and think to ourselves, “I don’t know their story, so I will not judge their behavior.” Has the disrespectful student just broken up with her boyfriend? Is the seemingly unreasonable parent at the end of their rope for any number of reasons? Is my sloppy and lazy son sending me a message? Are he and I, or the entire family, not spending enough time together? Has the person showing anger or using a sharp tone just lost a loved one? Just lost a job? Been battling depression?

Such reflection could eliminate a potentially negative response, and open the door to some positive possibilities. Maybe we counter their attitude or behavior by treating them with love and compassion. If something else is driving their behavior, they will appreciate our patience and understanding. If there is nothing driving the behavior (i.e. they are just disrespectful, unreasonable, lazy, or angry people), we at least set a good example for them. Perhaps we could even take it a step further by opening up a dialogue with the person, showing genuine concern and asking how we can help.

Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn’t, but I never find myself saying, “I wish I had judged them.”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s